Ep 60. How to Choose a Buyers Agent? Ask If You’ll Be One of Many or One of One

Ep 60. How to evaluate a Buyer's Agent
Buy Your Side - Hosted by Michelle May

How to choose a buyers agent in Sydney? I've been a buyers agent since 2008, back when we were very much a rare breed, and to become one, it doesn't take much at all. So in this episode I run you through what I'd check before you sign: licence and insurance, track record, transparent service, local knowledge, and a team behind them.

Start with the licence. In New South Wales, check that your buyers agent holds a Class 1 licence with NSW Fair Trading. It takes a minimum of three years to get there: a certificate of registration, then a Class 2 licence, then Class 1. They also need professional indemnity insurance, which is a requirement for all licence holders in NSW. Then ask how many years they've had as a buyers agent, not in real estate. In my opinion, someone with less than five years of experience as a buyers agent doesn't have the right to call themselves an expert.

A selling agent's job is to spin every negative into a positive. A buyers agent's job is to look critically at a property from all angles, and to advise you whether it's a good proposition, not just for your brief, but from a capital growth perspective.

So check their past purchases. We don't buy on the yellow roads, the very busy roads on Google Maps, because they're bad for your capital growth and you're not gonna enjoy living there. In my opinion, new and off the plan are very high risk propositions too.

When it comes to fees, a percentage of your budget is a conflict of interest. We charge a fixed fee based on the complexity of the search. Ask how long their agency agreements are for, how many clients they look after at the same time, and whether they take on competing briefs. We don't. So do you want to be one of many, or one of one?

If you're buying in Sydney's Inner West or Eastern Suburbs and want to talk through your search, book a free 20-minute consultation here.

If you want to know the questions to ask a buyers agent before you sign, listen to Buy Your Side 90 (What Should You Ask a Buyers Agent Before You Sign? Five Questions That Show Whose Side They're On).

Want the full list of questions to ask before you sign? Listen to Buy Your Side 90: What Should You Ask a Buyers Agent Before You Sign? Five Questions That Show Whose Side They’re On.

Chapters

0:00 How to choose a buyers agent in Sydney

1:54 Why the low barrier to entry matters to you

2:42 Check the licence: the road to a Class 1 licence in NSW

4:41 Professional indemnity insurance: ask the question

5:10 How many years as a buyers agent, not in real estate?

7:35 Track record: check the Google reviews and who wrote them

8:28 Check their past purchases: busy roads and off the plan

10:03 Flat fee vs percentage: how should a buyers agent charge?

11:19 Agency agreement time limits and pressure tactics

12:30 How many clients, and do they take competing briefs?

13:57 What should a buyers agent's due diligence include?

15:30 Why your buyers agent needs local knowledge

16:41 Referral fees: what must be disclosed

17:38 Why your buyers agent shouldn't work alone

Listener FAQs

How do you check a buyers agent's licence in NSW?

Check that they hold a Class 1 licence with NSW Fair Trading. In New South Wales it takes a minimum of three years to get there: a certificate of registration, then a Class 2 licence, then Class 1, working for someone experienced along the way. If it looks like someone has gone from nothing to a Class 1 licence, that's very much a red flag for me. They also need professional indemnity insurance, and any buyers agent who is cagey about that question is probably someone you don't really want to work with.

How much experience should a buyers agent have?

At least five years as a buyers agent, and continuously as a buyers agent. If someone says they've had 20 years of experience in the real estate industry, ask how many years they've actually had as a buyers agent. In my opinion, someone with less than five years of experience doesn't have the right to call themselves an expert.

Should a buyers agent charge a flat fee or a percentage?

A percentage of your budget is a conflict of interest. A tiered system may seem fairer, but it implies the higher your budget, the more work it is for the buyers agent, which is not always the case at all. The time we spend educating first home buyers is a lot more labour intensive. We charge a fixed fee based on the complexity of the search: if we're looking for a needle in a haystack, we charge more.

What should a buyers agent's due diligence include?

More than an automated valuation, because in my experience those are quite often wildly inaccurate. Ask whether they look at infrastructure projects, flood mapping, capital growth assessments and pricing research, plus development applications, zoning and new transport lines. All of these affect the property's value, how much you're prepared to pay, and whether you'd buy it at all.

Should a buyers agent take on competing briefs?

We don't, because how can I justify favouring one client over another when a particular property comes on the market? We have wait lists instead, and those clients are happy to wait, because when it's their turn they'll have that exclusivity. So do you want to be one of many, or one of one?

Speakers in today’s episode: 

Michelle May - Michelle May Buyers Agents

Follow Us:

Facebook  Instagram‍  ‍LinkedIn‍  ‍TikTok

Enjoy the show?

  • Don’t miss an episode, follow via iTunes. If you like it, please leave a review! 

  • Or, find us on the podcast app of your choice, such as Spotify.


This podcast has been produced and edited by Snappystreet Creative and Flâneur Creative Studio

Please note that any views or opinions presented in this podcast are solely those of the speakers, and do not necessarily represent those of any business. These views and opinions are general in nature, and do not take account of your personal objectives, financial situation and needs. Please consider whether it applies in your circumstances and seek professional advice wherever appropriate.

Previous
Previous

Ep 61. Mortgage Ready: What Really Hurts Your Borrowing Power

Next
Next

Ep 59. Buyer stories you need to hear